As an independent analytical company, we strive to highlight the best local organizations and businesses to help Hoosiers in their choices of high-quality service. In this article, we cover our top picks for Indianapolis Top 10 used car dealers.
Our team evaluated the dealerships based on Google customer reviews, industry standing, quality ratings, and awards for customer service and working conditions. Our procedure for listing involves manual research, two-tier review, and placement. Whether you want to buy or sell a used car in Indianapolis, these dealers should be the first stops on your journey.
1. Indy Auto Man
Indy Auto Man is a locally owned and operated used car dealership, located close to the center of Indianapolis, with a full set of services, including car buying and selling, maintenance, repair, customization, washing, and detailing. The auto dealer offers a diverse range of cars, trucks, SUVs, and minivans in different price categories for customers to explore and test drive. Indy Auto Man also accepts trade-ins of any make and model and provides in-house financing options for those who prefer not to pay the full price of their vehicle upfront. For customers from other cities of Indiana, the dealer offers online car sales with a complimentary Uber drive and delivery within 250 miles, as well as trade-in field assessment and pickup. Each vehicle comes with a free Carfax report, a 7-day return, and a 30-day price match guarantee. Indy Auto Man has 4.9 rating on Google Reviews, is recognized as one of the Best Indianapolis dealerships according to ThreeBestRated, and was named a Top Workplace in Central Indiana in 2024.
2. Andy Mohr Automotive
Andy Mohr Automotive Group provides a vast range of new and pre-owned models, along with dependable service and financing choices. With numerous locations and a substantial stock, they serve as a one-stop shop for all automotive requirements. Each location specializes in one brand, including Ford, GMC, Chevrolet, Buick, Honda, and Toyota. The Andy Mohr Automotive Group consists of 12 dealerships and service centers, four collision centers, and one heavy-duty truck center.
3. Tom Wood Automotive
At Tom Wood car dealership, IN, customers can always expect top-notch care. The dealer offers a wide range of new and used vehicles, transparent transactions, and certified maintenance in their service centers. The range of benefits also includes lifetime powertrain coverage, free car wash with a service visit. At Tom Wood’s premises, customers can enjoy cozy lounges with amenities like free Wi-Fi, TV, coffee, snacks, and a play area for kids.
4. Sharp Cars of Indy
Sharp Cars of Indy is highly regarded for its exceptional customer service and extensive inventory of both new and pre-owned vehicles, catering to customers in Indianapolis, Lawrence, and Fishers. The dealership is committed to offering seamless and personalized auto financing solutions, ensuring a stress-free and pleasant car-buying experience for every individual. The dealer provides a range of online services, including shopping inventory, e-documents, and credit applications. Customers can benefit from 15-mile pickup and delivery for maintenance or repairs.
5. Unlimited Motors
Unlimited Motors management has been in the automotive industry for over 45 years. They enjoy buying and selling vehicles and bring satisfaction to their customers. The dealer offers a wide array of used newer model vehicles ranging from domestic to exotic and top customer service in their 4 facilities in Indiana. Unlimited Motors adheres to implementing advanced tools, equipment, and technologies for inspecting and servicing cars in their inventory. They guarantee a road test and professional detailing for each vehicle. The dealer provides an array of financing options and factory warranty extensions.
6. Fishers Imports
Fishers Imports is a family-operated business. Since 2011, they have been offering quality, value, and a positive experience in the luxury pre-owned auto sales industry. Fishers Imports has set a higher standard for the car-buying journey by offering exceptional, non-pressure service, making it possible for customers to complete the entire buying process online or over the phone. All their vehicles come with a 90-day warranty.
7. Joe’s Auto Sales
Customers love the outstanding service at Joe’s Auto Sales, with many praising the prompt and effective help in discovering an affordably priced vehicle. The team goes the extra mile to ensure customers are well-informed about warranty details and the background of the vehicle they’re interested in. Unique aspects of Joe’s Auto Sales encompass their inclusive financing choices for individuals with varying credit histories and wide-ranging inventory spanning SUVs, cars, trucks, vans, motorcycles, and motorbikes. The team at Joe’s believes that everyone should have access to quality vehicles, irrespective of their credit status, and endeavors to streamline the car-buying process as much as possible.
8. Ray Skillman Auto Group
Ray Skillman Auto Group serves the Greenwood, Plainfield, and Indianapolis areas. They offer new, used, and certified pre-owned vehicles, favorable lease terms, and flexible auto financing. They are committed to customer satisfaction and a smooth car buying process. The Ray Skillman Auto Group represents several automotive brands, including Chevrolet, Ford, Buick, Kia, Hyundai, Mitsubishi, and Mazda. The Ray Skillman Auto Group’s qualified technicians from the parts department provide top-quality services from factory-scheduled maintenance to major repairs. The dealer works with national banks and local lenders to ensure attractive loan rates regardless of the customer’s budget and credit history.
9. Carmel Motors
Carmel Motors boasts a 5-acre location with a rich assortment of cars, SUVs, and trucks. The dealer claims to provide up-front market pricing and flexible financing options from 15+ lenders. Their assortment includes many car options priced below $20,000. Every vehicle receives from 3 to 10 days of intensive reconditioning before it goes up for resale. Carmel Motors provides free home delivery within 50 miles of the dealership.
10. Indy Motors
Indy Motors offers a wide selection of quality used cars, SUVs, and trucks to meet customers’ specifications and budgets from cost-effective vehicles for daily commutes to luxury cars. Every vehicle comes with a free Carfax report.
We hope our rating will help you choose your used car dealer and buy your dream car in Indianapolis. For a more informed decision, we recommend doing your research in person, for example, request your trade-in value or get pre-approved for a car loan. This way, you will gain an opportunity to estimate the communication and compare offers near you to pick the most advantageous deal.
